About The Author:

Got a story you want to share, or just need someone to talk to? Email Me! melody@toastedrav.com

I have a penchant for pizza, a love of books, and a strong cup of coffee always makes me smile. When I'm not writing for ToastedRav I like long walks on concrete sidewalks, hanging-lamp lit dinners, and a good bottle of Shiraz.
Updated 410 Days ago

Stephen King Vs Stephenie Meyer, It's On Like Donkey Kong

This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replying the story in its archived form does not constitute a re-publiccation of the story.

Horror writer Stephen King pimp slapped Stephenie Meyer in an interview with USA Weekend and the pseudo-literary world trembled. King, famous for writing about the macabre and the fantastic, said Meyer, famous for her vampires, "...can't write worth a darn," and some other none-such. While neither author is the stuff of high-brow literary circles, it is perfect for a good old fashioned cage match. Since neither one would probably agree to getting in the ring, we are going to have to settle for a few virtual bouts to see who really comes up on top.

Stephen King

Stephenie Meyer

Winner

Some believe that King is actually the one who killed John Lennon. Some believe that Meyer may be single handedly killing feminism. Meyer, because who really wanted John Lennon to die?
King's books are targeted at adults and test at a 5th or 6th grade reading level. Meyer's adult novel, "The Host" is targeted at adults and clocks in at a 4th grade reading level. King, though they both aren't exactly writing Shakespeare, 5th and 6th graders can beat up 4th graders.
King is kind of strange looking, in a Michael Jackson sort of way. Meyer is sort of strange looking, in a Michelle Trachtenberg sort of way. Meyer, because Jacko is just gross - plus it's probably better to look like a model than a surgical victim.
The Shining was a Stephen King book that was turned into a movie. Twilight was a Stephenie Meyer book that was turned into a movie. King, because The Shining will always be an amazing film, and as much as I like Twilight... "Here's Edward," just doesn't have the same ring.

 

Officially, it is a tie - especially if you count the round involving names spelled with the letters 's', 'p', and 'h'. Some would argue that they have both kinda stunk up the literary shelves, but both are necessary. Could you imagine how depressed the world would be if it were only filled with Nobkovs and DeLillos? It really comes down to a matter of taste. I, personally, prefer Stefenie Meyer. Though her books may be young adult there is enough literary allusion, sincerity and symbolism there for someone who wants more from their light read. I was a fan of King in 6th grade, but haven't touched the stuff since then. Really, when it comes to books that make the New York Times Best Sellers List, everyone has an opinion about what is good and bad, and just like King had his opinion about Meyer, everyone is entitled to it regardless of literary stature.

  • I love Stephen King, so I might have to disagree with this tie business...haha
  • Famous Women's College: Vassar

    Textbook they use in an English course on Prose: "On Writing" by Stephen King.

    http://catalogue.vassar.edu/courses/clcs/ (course 110b)

    Game set and match. Even educated women recognize King's genius over the "oh he's so broody I love him" tripe Meyer puts out. Want a great woman writer? Check out the stripper that wrote "Juno."

    UNC-Wilmington has a grad class on his works. http://www.uncw.edu/gls/stephenkinggls592.htm

    What does Meyer have? A bunch of vampires that look like "Fall Out Boy" And dialogue that the writers of "Sweet Valley High" find insipid. Here, suffer through for oneself:

    "Facing my pallid reflection in the mirror, I was forced to admit that I was lying to myself. It wasn't just physically that I'd never fit in. And if I couldn't find a niche in a school with three thousand people, what were my chances here? So I'm just going to slash my wrists in a cry for help, right after I take some black hair dye and a flat iron to my bangs. The End."

    Okay, I added that last bit.
  • Hmmm, the title of his book sounds a lot like the book they gave me in my creative writing class and again in my teaching writing class, it's a classic "On Writing Well," by Zinsser - used more schools than not. Ok, so maybe it is just his titling skills that are lacking - after all he *did* write a book about writing. I guess I will have to check that out... after all I haven't read King since he lost my interest in 6th grade and if he has something to add to the world of writing then I would be interested.

    For the record, even as a Stephenie Meyer fan I am not saying she is much better than he is... I am kind of saying they both suck in regards to the majority of the printed world but so did The Davinci Code and everyone loved that, too. In fact, you might remember that one of the most wretched books ever printed was a New York Times Bestseller - The Devil Wears Prada. They all serve their purpose but filling a void for great writing it is not.
  • It seems to me that all the characters in Meyer's literature all dress and act alike. You know who else dressed and acted alike? THE NAZIS!!!

    [/internet argument]
  • [/internet argument] Seems to me all of Stephen King's characters have super natural powers... you know who else has super natural powers? The Psychic Friends Network [/internet argument]
  • Hmmm, considering that looks were in the official breakdown I think it's getting a bit too serious in here... If you like King, good, if you like Meyer, great, but neither are Faulkner or Joyce. I think the comparisons were fair, both are pop culture writers that appeal to the same readership. King brought any criticism levied on himself by being pompous and self-righteous during an interview. In my opinion it was just a rant on the fact that King's fans (and their daughters) were leaving his books on the shelves and picking up that all too familiar tale of love struck vampires...
    But then, what do I know, most of the books I read were written before 1950. (I did like Stand By Me, a film adaptation of a S King short story... but maybe it was the acting)
  • I have loved King's book and movies for year's.

What do you think?

We want to hear from you! Take five seconds to join ToastedRav.com or log in.
© Copyright 2010 ToastedRav.com and Bonneville International. An Equal Opportunity Employer all rights reserved.